hub motor vs. mid drive

Electric Bike Motor Choice: hub motor vs mid drive

Spread the love

There are two main types of electric bike motors: a hub drive and a mid-drive. This blog post will explain these systems, how they work, and their pros and cons. We will also compare and analyze them in terms of performance, efficiency, power, terrain, rider preferences, cost, and maintenance. By the end of this post, you will better understand the differences between hub drive and mid-drive motors and how to make the best decision for your electric bike.

 

Pros and Cons of Hub Drive Motors


A hub drive motor is a motor that is mounted on the wheel hub of the electric bike. Depending on the bike’s design, it can be either on the front or rear wheel. A hub drive motor directly drives the wheel without connecting to the bike’s chain or gears. This means the wheel’s speed determines the motor’s speed and vice versa.

 

Advantages of hub drive motors

  • They are simple and easy to install. You don’t need to modify the bike’s frame or drivetrain to fit a hub drive motor. You need to replace the wheel with a hub motor wheel and connect it to the battery and controller.
  • They are relatively cheap and widely available. Hub drive motors are among the oldest and most standard electric bike motors. You can find them in various sizes, shapes, and power levels. They are also more affordable than mid-drive motors.
  • They are reliable and low maintenance. Hub drive motors have fewer moving parts than mid-drive motors, making them less likely to break down or wear out. They also don’t affect the bike’s chain or gears, so you don’t need to worry about adjusting or replacing them more often.

 

Disadvantages of hub drive motors

  • Adding weight and reducing the balance. Hub drive motors add extra weight to the wheel, which can affect the handling and stability of the bike. They also make the bike less balanced, as one wheel is heavier.
  • Reduced efficiency and range. Hub drive motors have a fixed gear ratio, so they cannot adapt to different speeds or terrains. This can result in wasted energy and reduced battery life. For example, if you are going uphill or against the wind, a hub drive motor will need more power and torque. If you go downhill or with the wind, a hub drive motor will spin faster than necessary and generate excess heat.
  • Limitted customization and performance. Hub drive motors have limited options for customization and upgrade. You cannot change the gear ratio or use different wheels or tires with a hub drive motor. You cannot use regenerative braking or pedal assist with a hub drive motor. These features can enhance the performance and efficiency of an electric bike.

 

Pros and Cons of Mid-Drive Motors


Mid-drive motors are electric bike motors mounted at the frame’s bottom bracket, where the pedals are. They drive the chain or belt that connects to the rear wheel. Mid-drive motors are becoming more popular among electric bike enthusiasts as they offer advantages over hub motors. However, they also have some drawbacks that need to be considered.

 

Advantages of mid-drive motors

  • Better weight distribution: Mid-drive motors place the weight of the motor in the center of the bike, improving the bike’s balance and handling. This also reduces the wheels’ unsprung weight, improving the suspension performance and ride quality.
  • Higher efficiency: Mid-drive motors can use the bike’s gears to optimize the torque and speed of the motor for different riding conditions. This means they can deliver more power with less energy consumption, resulting in longer battery life and range.
  • Better climbing ability: Mid-drive motors can leverage the bike’s gears to provide more torque at low speeds, essential for climbing steep hills or carrying heavy loads. They also reduce the stress on the spokes and rims of the rear wheel, which can be damaged by hub motors under high torque.
  • More compatibility: Mid-drive motors can fit on most types of bikes, as they do not interfere with the wheel size or brake system. They can also work with drivetrains, such as derailleurs, internal gear hubs, or belt drives.

 

Disadvantages of mid-drive motors

  • Higher cost: Mid-drive motors are generally more expensive than hub motors, requiring more complex and sophisticated components and electronics. They also need a special frame design to accommodate the motor and mounting brackets.
  • Higher maintenance: Mid-drive motors put more strain on the bike’s drivetrain, increasing the wear and tear on the chain, cassette, derailleur, and chainring. They also require more frequent adjustments and replacements of these parts, which can add to the maintenance cost and hassle.
  • More noise: Mid-drive motors produce more noise than hub motors, generating more vibration and friction in the drivetrain. They also have a higher RPM (revolutions per minute) than hub motors, which makes them louder at higher speeds.

 

Comparison and Analysis of Hub Drive vs. Mid-Drive Systems


In this section, we will compare and analyze electric bike hub drive and mid-drive systems in terms of performance, efficiency, and power. We will also discuss how the terrain and rider preferences affect the choice of the motor system and the cost and maintenance requirements of each system.

 

Performance

Hub drive systems have a simple and direct connection between the motor and the wheel, which means they can provide a consistent and smooth ride. However, they also have some drawbacks, such as increased weight on the wheel, reduced traction and handling, and lower torque. Mid-drive systems have a more complex and indirect connection between the motor and the wheel, which means they can provide a more responsive and dynamic ride. They also have some advantages, such as reduced weight on the wheel, improved traction and handling, and higher torque.

 

Efficiency

Hub drive systems have a fixed gear ratio between the motor and the wheel, which means they can only operate at optimal efficiency at a certain speed range. The motor will consume more energy and generate more heat if the speed is too low or too high. Mid-drive systems have a variable gear ratio between the motor and the wheel, which means they can adjust to different speed ranges and terrain conditions. They can also use the bike’s gears to optimize the motor’s efficiency.

 

Power

Hub drive systems have a limited power output due to their fixed gear ratio and direct connection to the wheel. They can only deliver as much power as the wheel can handle, which may need to be more for steep hills or heavy loads. Mid-drive systems have a higher power output due to their variable gear ratio and indirect connection to the wheel. They can deliver more power than the wheel can handle, which can be helpful for steep hills or heavy loads.

 

Terrain and rider preferences

Hub drive systems are more suitable for flat or moderate terrain, where the speed range is relatively constant, and the traction and handling are not critical. They are also more suitable for casual or recreational riders who prefer a simple and easy ride. Mid-drive systems are more suitable for hilly or rough terrain, where the speed range is variable, and the traction and handling are important. They are also more ideal for sporty or adventurous riders who prefer a responsive and dynamic ride.

 

Cost and maintenance 

Hub drive systems are generally cheaper and easier to install and maintain than mid-drive systems. They have fewer moving parts and less wear and tear on the bike’s components. However, they also have disadvantages, such as increased tire wear, reduced spoke life, and difficulty changing a flat tire. Mid-drive systems are generally more expensive and harder to install and maintain than hub-drive systems. They have more moving parts and wear and tear on the bike’s components. However, they also have some benefits, such as reduced tire wear, increased spoke life, and ease of changing a flat tire.

 

Final Thoughts on Hub Motor Vs. Mid Drive Motors


Choosing between a hub motor and a mid-drive motor for your electric bike can be difficult. Hub motors are simple, cheap, and reliable but add weight and reduce efficiency. Mid-drive motors are more efficient, powerful, and compatible but are more expensive and require more maintenance. The choice depends on your riding style, terrain, and budget. Hope this comparison and analysis of hub motor vs. mid drive has helped you make an informed decision.

 

FAQ


Is mid-drive or hub motor better?

Mid-drive motors are integrated along the bike’s center between the pedals and are more common in expensive electric bikes. One of the most significant advantages of mid-drive motors is that they can take advantage of your bike’s gears, which makes them more efficient and powerful at different speeds.

Hub motors are located on wheels and are common in cheaper e-bikes.

One of the biggest advantages of hub motors is that they require little or no maintenance, as they are an independent drive system with few moving parts.

 

Is a hub motor best on an electric bike?

A hub motor can be best on an electric bike if you prefer a more straightforward, cheaper, and more reliable system that does not depend on your bike’s gears.

 

Are hub motors good for hills?

Hub motors can be good for hills with enough torque and power but may struggle at lower speeds or with heavier loads.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *