throttle vs pedal assist

Electric Bike Throttle vs. Pedal Assist: Which is the Better Option?

Spread the love

Two main types of electric bike power systems are throttle and pedal assist. These systems determine how the rider activates and controls the electric motor. In this blog post, we will explain the differences between these two systems, compare their advantages and disadvantages, and help you decide which option is better for you.

 

Throttle vs. Pedal Assist


Throttle and pedal assist are two different ways of activating and controlling the electric motor on an e-bike. A throttle system allows the rider to use a twist-grip or a thumb-press lever to control the amount of power the motor delivers manually. The rider can use the throttle only, without or in combination with pedaling. A pedal-assist system, also known as pedelec or PAS, uses a sensor to detect the rider’s pedaling effort and automatically adjusts the level of motor assistance accordingly. The rider can choose from different assistance levels, usually from low to high, or turn off the motor completely.

 

Throttle

A throttle system is similar to a motorcycle or a scooter. It allows you to control the speed and power of the electric motor by twisting a handlebar or pressing a button. You can use the throttle without pedaling at all or pedal along with the throttle for extra assistance. The throttle system gives you full control over how much or how little electric assistance you want at any time.

 

Pedal Assist

A pedal assist system, also known as pedelec or PAS, differs from a throttle system in that it only activates the electric motor when you pedal. The pedal assist system uses sensors to detect how hard and fast you are pedaling and then provides an appropriate level of electric assistance based on your settings. You can adjust the pedal assist level from low to high, depending on how much help you want from the motor. The pedal assist system requires you to always pedal for any electric assistance.

 

Comparison

Both throttle and pedal assist systems have pros and cons, depending on your preferences and riding style. Here are some of the main factors to consider when comparing the two systems:

 

Ease of use: A throttle system is more accessible than a pedal-assist system, as you don’t have to worry about pedaling or adjusting the level of assistance. You twist or press the throttle and go. A pedal assist system may require some learning curve to get used to the different levels of assistance and how they affect your pedaling.

 

Range: A pedal assist system is more efficient than a throttle system, as it only uses the battery when you pedal. This means that a pedal assist system can extend your electric bike’s battery life and range. A throttle system uses the battery constantly, regardless of whether you pedaling. This means that a throttle system can drain the battery faster and reduce the range of your electric bike.

 

Speed: A throttle system can provide faster acceleration and higher top speed than a pedal assist system, as it can deliver more power to the motor without any limitations. A pedal assist system can only provide as much power as your pedaling input allows, and it may have a speed limit that cuts off the motor when you reach a certain speed.

 

Exercise: A pedal assist system can provide more exercise than a throttle system, as it encourages you to pedal along with the motor. Depending on your fitness level and goals, you can adjust the level of assistance to make your pedaling easier or harder. A throttle system can provide less exercise than a pedal-assist system, allowing you to ride without pedaling. You may rely on the motor too much and need more physical activity.

 

Riding Situations

Depending on your riding situation, one system may be more suitable. Here are some examples of situations where each system may have the edge over the other:

 

Commuting: 

If you commute to work or school on an electric bike, you may prefer a pedal assist system over a throttle system. A pedal assist system can help you save battery life and range, avoid sweating too much, and get some exercise along the way. A throttle system may be less ideal for commuting, as it can drain your battery faster, make you sweat more, and provide less exercise.

 

Leisure:

If you are riding an electric bike for leisure or fun, you may prefer a throttle system over a pedal assist system. A throttle system can give you more freedom and excitement, as you can control the speed and power of the motor with ease. You can also enjoy riding without pedaling to relax or enjoy the scenery. A pedal assist system may be less fun for leisure riding, as it requires you to pedal constantly and limits your speed and power.

 

Hills: 

If riding an electric bike on hilly terrain, you may prefer a pedal assist system over a throttle system. A pedal assist system can help you climb hills more easily and comfortably, providing smooth and consistent assistance based on your pedaling effort. You can also adjust the level of assistance to match the hill’s steepness. A throttle system may be less helpful for hill climbing, as it may provide too.

 

Choosing Between Throttle and Pedal Assist

 

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Throttle and Pedal Assist


Level of Control

One of the main factors to consider is the level of control you want over your electric bike. A throttle system allows you to control the speed and power of your electric bike with a twist or a thumb lever, similar to a motorcycle. You can use the throttle to accelerate, maintain speed or coast without pedaling. On the other hand, a pedal assist system requires you to pedal to activate the electric motor. The motor will provide assistance based on the level of pedaling effort or speed you choose. You can adjust the level of assistance with a display or a button on the handlebar.

 

Your Preference

Your system is more convenient and comfortable depending on your preference. Some riders may prefer the throttle system because it gives them more freedom and flexibility to ride at their own pace and style. They can use the throttle to overcome hills, headwinds, or traffic without sweat. Others may prefer the pedal assist system because it gives them more exercise and a natural feeling of riding a bike. They can also enjoy the benefits of pedaling, such as improved cardiovascular health, muscle strength, and balance.

 

Battery Life and Range

Another factor to consider is your electric bike’s battery life and range. Generally, a throttle system consumes more battery power than a pedal-assist system because it does not rely on your pedaling input. This means you may need to recharge your battery more often or carry a spare battery if you plan to ride long distances or durations. A pedal assist system, on the other hand, consumes less battery power because it uses your pedaling input to optimize the motor efficiency. This means you can extend your battery life and range by pedaling more or choosing a lower level of assistance.

 

Riding Needs and Goals

Depending on your riding needs and goals, one system may be more suitable. Some riders may prefer the throttle system because it allows them to travel faster and farther with less effort and fatigue. They can also use the throttle to save battery power, such as climbing steep hills or riding against strong winds. Others may prefer the pedal assist system because it saves them battery power and money by pedaling more and using less electricity. They can also use the pedal assist system to challenge themselves and improving their fitness by choosing a higher level of assistance.

 

Common Myths and Misconceptions About Throttle and Pedal Assist


This section will address some common myths and misconceptions about throttle and pedal assist and provide factual information and research to help you make an informed decision.

 

Myth 1: Throttle is easier and more convenient than pedal assist.

Some people may think that throttle is easier and more convenient than pedal assist because it allows you to control the speed and power of the electric bike with a simple twist or push of a button. However, this is only sometimes true. The throttle may be easier in some situations, such as starting from a stop or climbing a steep hill, but it also has some drawbacks. For example, the throttle can drain the battery faster than the pedal assist because it uses more power without any input from the rider. The throttle can also make the ride less smooth and stable because it can cause sudden acceleration or deceleration that may affect the balance and handling of the bike. Throttle can also be illegal or restricted in some areas, depending on the local laws and regulations.

 

Pedal assist, on the other hand, may seem more complicated or less convenient than throttle because it requires you to pedal to activate the electric motor. However, this is not necessarily true either. Pedal assist can make the ride easier and more enjoyable because it provides a natural and intuitive way of controlling the speed and power of the electric bike. Pedal assist can also extend the battery life because it uses less energy and adjusts to the rider’s input. Pedal assistance can also make the ride smoother and safer because it can prevent sudden acceleration or deceleration that may affect the balance and handling of the bike. Pedal assistance can also be legal and accepted in most areas if it meets certain criteria.

 

Therefore, the throttle is only sometimes easier and more convenient than pedal assist, and vice versa. The best option depends on your preference, riding style, terrain, and legal situation.

Myth 2: Pedal assist is more exercise than throttle.

Pedal assist may be more exercise than throttle because it requires you to pedal to activate the electric motor. However, this is not necessarily true either. Pedal assist does not mean you have to pedal hard or fast to get assistance from the electric motor. Most pedal assist systems have different levels of assistance you can choose from, depending on how much effort you want to put in. For example, you can choose a low level of assistance if you want to get more exercise or a high level if you wish to less exercise. Depending on your mood or situation, you can also change the level of assistance at any time during your ride.

 

A throttle does not mean you do not have to pedal to get assistance from the electric motor. Most throttle systems have a limit on how fast or how far they can go without pedaling. For example, some throttle systems have a speed limit of 20 mph or a distance limit of 20 miles before they cut off. Some throttle systems also have a pedal sensor that detects whether you are pedaling and adjusts the power accordingly. Therefore, you can still get some exercise with throttle if you want to.

 

Therefore, pedal assist is only sometimes more exercise than throttle, and vice versa. The amount of exercise you get depends on how you use the system and how much effort you put in.

 

Myth 3: Throttle is more fun than pedal assist.

Some people may think that throttle is more fun than pedal assist because it gives you more control and freedom over the speed and power of the electric bike. However, this is also a matter of personal preference and opinion. Some people may find throttle more fun because they like the feeling of instant acceleration and speed that throttle provides. However, some people may find the throttle less fun because they feel disconnected from the bike and the riding experience it creates. Some people may also find the throttle tedious or tiring after a while because they do not have to do anything but twist or push a button.

Pedal assist may seem less fun than throttle because it limits your control and freedom over the speed and power of the electric bike. However, some people may find pedal assist more fun because they like the natural and seamless integration between their pedaling and the motor assistance pedal assist provides.

 

Final Thoughts on Pedal Assist vs. Throttle


Choosing between electric bike throttle and pedal assist systems depends on various factors, such as your riding style, terrain, and personal preferences. While throttle systems may offer more control and speed, pedal assist systems are more efficient and provide a more natural riding experience. Ultimately, your best option will depend on your needs and goals.

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *